Increased pressure at airports

Increased pressure at airports

The proposed ID checks for passengers on flights within the Schengen Area have sparked debate with several arguments both for and against, as well as potential impacts on the aviation industry and travelers.

Arguments for ID Checks

The main arguments in favor of the ID checks revolve around enhanced security, improved border control, and compliance with existing legal provisions.

• Security Enhancement: Increased ID and biometric checks aim to strengthen security by better managing migration, preventing irregular migration, and reducing risks related to terrorism and cross-border crime.
• Improved Border Control: Reintroducing ID checks and biometric entry-exit systems (EES) enables more accurate tracking of travelers entering and leaving the Schengen Area, especially for non-EU nationals.
• Compliance with Schengen Borders Code: States are invoking existing legal provisions allowing temporary reintroduction of internal border controls in cases of serious threats, suggesting the measure is legally supported and deemed necessary by governments.

Arguments Against ID Checks

On the other hand, opponents of the ID checks raise concerns about travel delays, privacy, industry impact, and complexity.

• Travel Delays and Inconvenience: ID checks and biometric scans increase processing times at airports and other transport hubs, causing delays and longer queues for travelers.
• Impact on Travelers’ Privacy: Collecting biometric data raises concerns about privacy, data security, and how long the data will be stored.
• Complicated Travel Experience: The new procedures require non-EU travelers to undergo biometric registration on their first entry, and children may also be required to submit data, adding complexity particularly for families or less frequent travelers.
• Potential Industry Impact: Aviation and travel sectors could face operational challenges due to increased border control measures, possible declines in spontaneous travel, and passenger dissatisfaction.

Potential Impacts

| Impact Category | Details | |---------------------|------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------| | Travel Experience | Increased waiting times, extra steps at border control, required biometric data submission for non-EU visitors. | | Aviation Industry | Possible operational delays, need for updated protocols, and potential decrease in passenger numbers due to border hassles. | | Security | Enhanced ability to detect overstays, track entries and exits, reducing illegal migration and boosting safety. | | Privacy | Raises concerns over biometric data collection and retention, necessitating robust data protection measures. |

Additional Context

It is worth noting that some countries, like Italy, are simultaneously relaxing certain checks internally, indicating a complex evolving landscape of travel regulations in Europe. The system initially applies predominantly to non-EU nationals, with EU and EFTA citizens largely exempt from biometric checks. The EES rollout begins October 12, 2025.

In summary, while the ID and biometric checks are intended to enhance security and migration control within Schengen flights, they also bring trade-offs related to travel convenience, privacy concerns, and operational impacts on airlines and airports. The ongoing balance between free movement and security shapes these evolving policies.

The aviation industry argues that identity checks should remain a task of the Federal Police. The BDL's warnings highlight potential challenges in implementing the proposed ID checks by airlines. The aviation industry warns that airlines taking on sovereign tasks could cause additional burdens for vacationers and travelers. The proposed measure aims to ensure the identity of flight passengers can be used for police purposes in case of crimes. The proposal for stricter controls is currently being considered by the Federal Council. The BDL's stance reinforces industry's opposition to the proposed responsibility shift to airlines.

• Maintaining a secure lifestyle during travel could be challenging due to the increased processing times at airports and other transport hubs resulting from the ID checks and biometric scans.
• The debate over ID checks for passengers on flights within the Schengen Area extends to the impact of these checks on the traveling lifestyle, particularly concerning travel delays and complicated travel experiences, especially for non-EU travelers.

Read also: